From The Labs

Breast cancer tumors remotely disrupt immune response that could stop their own growth

Research has shown that breast cancer can have significant consequences in the entire body even before it metastasizes or spreads to other organs. For instance, tumors can send molecular signals to the bone marrow, the birthplace of immune cells, packaged in tiny vesicles or sacs that travel from the breast tumor to the marrow. These signals disrupt the ecosystem inside the bone marrow, leading to an immune response that does not attack the tumor but favors its growth instead.

Dr. Xiang Zhang

“To understand how this happens, we characterized the organization of the bone marrow in breast cancer animal models before the tumor had metastasized,” said corresponding author Dr. Xiang H.-F. Zhang, William T. Butler, M.D., Endowed Chair for Distinguished Faculty and interim director of the Lester and Sue Smith Breast Center at Baylor.

Microscopy view of a bone marrow section in the presence (PyMT-N-bearing) and absence (sham) of breast cancer tumors in an animal model. Notice that the tumor promotes dramatic changes in the organization of the bone marrow. Additional experiments showed that this in turn disrupts the normal anti-tumor response. Image courtesy of the authors/Cell Stem Cell, 2023.

The team found that even small tumors can affect the body profoundly as they trigger multiple changes in the bone marrow.

“Breast cancer tumors promote the over production of bone marrow cells called osteoprogenitor cells, which will later contribute to the formation of new bone,” said first author Dr. Xiaoxin Hao, postdoctoral associate in the Zhang lab.

In addition, other cells, the progenitors of cells that give rise to immune cells, also grow in numbers. Importantly, these progenitors also change their typical location within the bone marrow, relocating near the osteoprogenitor cells and establishing a new cell-to-cell communication with these cells, particularly with a subset called granulocyte-monocyte progenitors (GMPs).

Dr. Xiaoxin Hao

“We think that this osteoprogenitor-GMP communication is key, because GMPs give rise to neutrophils and monocytes, immune cells that have long been known to accumulate in some breast cancer tumors in patients and breast cancer mouse models and help promote tumor growth by suppressing the anti-tumor immune response,” Hao said.

Takes time to recover

The researchers were surprised to find that after they removed the tumor, which they considered the source of the problem, the disruption of the bone marrow did not recover immediately.

“We observed this in animal models,” Hao said. “In some patients, we have seen that even more than 40 weeks after removing the tumor, increased numbers of neutrophils remain in their blood, which is clinically relevant.”

In some cases, tumor removal is followed by immunotherapy, which relies on an intact immune system for its success. “Our findings suggest that at least in some patients the immune system is still compromised after removing the tumor, likely reducing the beneficial effects of immunotherapy,” Zhang said.

Implications for metastasis

In addition, the findings have implications for metastasis. Metastasis may arise years or even decades after the tumor has been surgically removed seeded by residual cancer cells left behind after the surgery. “An immunosuppressive effect lingering after the surgery may create an environment favorable for the residual cancer cells to proliferate and metastasize,” Hao said.

Accelerating recovery

The researchers also identified protein MMP-13 as an essential mediator of the crosstalk between osteoprogenitor cells and GMPs. “We showed that if we eliminate or inhibit MMP-13, we can accelerate the recovery of the immune system and restore the efficacy of immunotherapies,” Hao said.

Our findings suggest a new modality of treatment that is very different from the current strategies. It’s not targeting the cancer cells, it’s not targeting immune T cells that attack cancer cells, it’s targeting the whole organism. It’s trying to remove a kind of shadow cast over the entire immune system,” Zhang said.

“This is just the beginning of a series of studies on how tumors alter the whole body. Our findings support continuing our research on this path, and we hope it will lead to the identification of improved treatments for cancer patients.”

Read all the details of this study in the journal Cell Stem Cell.

Other contributors to this work include Yichao Shen, Nan Chen, Weijie Zhang, Elizabeth Valverde, Ling Wu, Hilda L. Chan, Zhan Xu, Liqun Yu, Yang Gao, Igor Bado, Laura Natalee Michie, Charlotte Helena Rivas, Luis Becerra-Dominguez, Sergio Aguirre, Bradley C. Pingel, Yi-Hsuan Wu, Fengshuo Liu, Yunfeng Ding, David G. Edwards, Jun Liu, Angela Alexander, Naoto T. Ueno, Po-Ren Hsueh, Chih-Yen Tu, Liang-Chih Liu, Shu-Hsia Chen, Mien-Chie Hung and Bora Lim. The authors are affiliated with one or more of the following institutions: Baylor College of Medicine, University of Texas MD Anderson Cancer Center-Houston, University of Hawai’i Cancer Center, Medical University Hospital and Houston Methodist Research Institute.

The study is supported by the U.S. Department of Defense DAMD W81XWH-16-1-0073 (Era of Hope Scholarship), NCI CA183878, NCI CA251950, NCI CA221946, NCI CA227904, NCI CA253533, DAMD W81XWH-20-1-0375, Breast Cancer Research Foundation and McNair Medical Institute. Further support was provided by NIH grants (S10OD023469, S10OD025240, P30EY002520, CA125123 and RR024574) and CPRIT grants RP200504 and CPRIT-RP180672.


By Ana María Rodríguez, Ph.D.


Receive From the Labs via email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *